79, no. Although Chinas toll highways are world-renowned, they suffer from indisputable operational inefficiencies. And finally, how much has been the annual collection of various tolls across the country over the years? 1, pp. 01:25 Xi sets tone for future Belt and Road development at Beijing forum TCA is comprised of two Joint Powers Authorities formed by the California legislature in 1986 to plan, finance, construct and operate the 73, 133, 241 and 261 Toll Roads in Orange County. Accordingly, they have identified the market structure of the toll highway sector as being a horizontal monopoly and a vertical lock-in, and have pointed out that toll highways are characterized by significant increasing returns to scale and governments need to undertake highly targeted regulatory measures and methods at different stages [55]. In addition, it is rare to find papers that analyze the inefficient operation of the toll road industry from the perspective of economies of scale. Facing public pressure, Sun Yonghong, the deputy director of the Ministry of Transportations Roads Bureau, explained in an interview with Caijing that 80 percent of toll roads income went to pay principal and interest on loan debts. 5. 1, pp. The research on administrative monopoly and economic performance has gradually expanded from qualitative analysis to quantitative analysis to empirical testing of specific impact mechanisms. 195203, 2012. The US$668 million project was financed by the state-owned China Communications Construction Company, CRBC's parent company. Toll roads across the country collect more than 400 billion yuan (US$60 billion) each year. 12, pp. 2, pp. 2, pp. [15], Zhang et al. 448, no. 2, pp. The pooled revenue will also be used to repay loans and expansion support for allocated to the Provinces toll road operating companies on a formula basis developed to reflect the legitimate rewards for investors in those companies promoting more successful Expressways but sufficient to sustain others at least in a good state of repair and maintenance, even if investors bear some losses. Road transport forms a vital and fast growing sector of the transport sector, supporting trade and growth through the movement of goods and people, allowing economic specialization, spreading skills and enhancing productivity. 6, pp. In fact, it has assets in the developed coastal part of the country, where traffic volume is high, as well as in the less-developed provinces of Guizhou and Guangxi, where volume is low but growing fast. Excessive administrative monopoly is the reason that the increase of scale cannot improve the efficiency of the toll road industry. 8186, 2012. This strategy not only lacks social responsibility, but is also illegal. Statista. 1, pp. In recent years, the publicprivate partnership (PPP) mode has been favored by industry managers because PPP can not only introduce private capital but also pay attention to the competitive advantages so as to achieve efficiency improvement theoretically [7], However, PPP had not been supported by empirical evidence in practice, and concession did not significantly improve operational efficiency in toll highways [8]. Please do not hesitate to contact me. Since there are no toll roads in general in Hainan and Tibet, after removing the Hainan, Tibet, Hong Kong, Macao, and Taiwan regions, this paper selects the remaining 29 provinces as research samples. Pertaining to data selection, in view of the special nature of the toll road industrys operations and management, the provincial panel data are used for empirical analysis. Annual car sales worldwide 2010-2022, with a forecast for 2023, Number of cars sold in the U.S. 1951-2021, Battery electric vehicles in use worldwide 2016-2021, Annual gas prices in the United States 1990-2021, Automotive industry worldwide - statistics & facts, Motorcycle industry in the United States - statistics & facts, Profit from additional features with an Employee Account. Descriptive statistics of the main variables are shown in Table 3. The Toll business was founded in Newcastle, Australia in 1888 by Albert Toll when he began hauling coal by horse and cart. This special nature is manifested in the bureaucratic organizational system with the integration of political centralization and financial decentralization [49], which can be referred to as an authoritarian system with regional decentralization [50, 51]. Another problem thats specific to CMHP is that acquiring toll-road assets from its parent isnt a straightforward matter. The Minister, by Toll Road Order dated April 8, 2002, granted a concession to NROCC to design, finance, construct, maintain and operate Highway 2000 and levy, collect ant retain toll with respect to the toll road. Hence, the debt risk is emerging. (STR/AFP/Getty Images), What Chinas Highway Robbery-Style Toll Roads Say About its Economy, a well-known Chinese economist and blogger, Facing public pressure, Sun Yonghong, the deputy director of the Ministry of Transportations Roads Bureau, explained in an interview with. This study investigates this genuine problem and attempts to find a solution to it. Our products make it easy to pay your tolls for any Sydney road, including: Cross City Tunnel Eastern Distributor Hills M2 Lane Cove Tunnel Military Road E-Ramp M5 East Motorway M5 South-West Motorway As a result, most Expressways are tolled. A number of levels and institutions have been set up, and the increase in economies of scale is first shackled by the operating system. 63, no. For the construction of toll roads, charge management, maintenance, service area operations, etc., the market mechanisms can play a role, and the effective allocation of economic resources should be returned to the market to ensure the priority role of the market mechanisms in resource allocation. Column (II) reports the impact of toll road density on scale efficiency of toll road industry (). [Online]. 8, pp. Accessed January 18, 2023. https://www.statista.com/statistics/759691/china-toll-road-length-by-ownership/, Ministry of Transport of China. Meanwhile, PT Jasa Marga Tbk (JSMR) also released 20% shares in three segments, namely Batang - Semarang, Solo - Ngawi, and Ngawi - Kertosono, to RDPT last year. Over a short period of 20years, the scale of Chinas toll highways expanded to rank first globally. Presently, Chinas total toll road debt has accumulated to 4.45 trillion yuan ($660 billion). Access to this and all other statistics on 80,000 topics from, Show sources information Companies that build private toll roads are pressing states to assume more financial risk of traffic not meeting expectations, . For one thing, toll rates are determined by individual provincial governments. As a Premium user you get access to background information and details about the release of this statistic. This algorithm, in turn, causes the decision units of different periods to lack the benchmark for vertical comparison. The Toll Roads are owned by the state of California and operated by The Transportation Corridor Agencies (TCA). 6879, 2013. However, during 20102017, the compound annual growth rate of toll road mileage is 1.03%, while the annual compound growth rate of the SEC is only 0.56%, which is much smaller than the former. From the provincial and industrial perspectives, this study further verifies how an administrative monopoly restricts the transformation from scale to total factor productivity and scale efficiency through the unique operation pattern in the toll highway sector. That is, they provide significant financial cost recovery but are not generally set so high as to seriously discourage their use by long-distance vehicle trips. Please create an employee account to be able to mark statistics as favorites. 120-121, 2013. Common arguments are: that roads constitute essential social infrastructure and should be provided free to users; that no other country has so many tolled-roads; that as soon as the loans for construction have been repaid tolls are no longer justified; that tolls are expensive to collect; that after the roads are built they should be used to divert the maximum traffic from existing lower-standard roads; that toll-rates are sub-optimal with great variability even over a single interconnected route. To resolve the problem, the first step is to ascertain the cause of debt accumulation in the sector. The vignette revenues would be consolidated into a pooled revenue at the province level and to support network-wide maintenance and rehabilitation, as well as use the excess funds to cross-subsidies network expansion. Velinov et al. Overview and forecasts on trending topics, Industry and market insights and forecasts, Key figures and rankings about companies and products, Consumer and brand insights and preferences in various industries, Detailed information about political and social topics, All key figures about countries and regions, Market forecast and expert KPIs for 600+ segments in 150+ countries, Insights on consumer attitudes and behavior worldwide, Business information on 60m+ public and private companies, Detailed information for 35,000+ online stores and marketplaces. CMHP became a toll road operator in 2004, when its parent, the state-owned China Merchants Group (CMG), injected five toll roads into the company. Are you interested in testing our corporate solutions? The use of an administrative monopoly not only incurs transaction costs but also reaps corresponding revenue. Comparing Portfolio Performance of Some Singapore Robo Advisers (2023 Update 2.4 Years Later). Some government funded roads in China have been transformed into toll roads before the 15-year loan period expired, with the loan repayment period intentionally extended. [34] examined the effect of the administrative monopoly tariffs on the regional energy efficiency and proved that administrative barriers not only affect the efficiency and competitiveness of enterprises but also affect the final price of goods and services of final consumers. Tolls are justified even after loan is repaid. As a Premium user you get access to the detailed source references and background information about this statistic. Industry-level control variables: toll road management expense , toll road maintenance expense , and toll road toll station number .The proxy variable for administrative monopoly is the ratio of the scale of governmental loan-repayment toll highways to the total scale of toll highways, and the ratio of cumulative capital funds for the construction of governmental loan-payment toll highways to the total investment of the toll highway sector; thus, the intersection terms are recorded as and, respectively, in Table 9. All operators are under the auspices of Toll Road Regulatory Agency (Badan Pengatur Jalan Tol, BPJT) of the Ministry of . The reference set is the sum of all periods sets; i.e., the common reference set for each period is. Indeed, Jiang says it would be safe for CMHP to raise its gearing to 60%. Its headquarters are in Houston. Meanwhile, its earnings are set to nearly double to HK$502 million in FY2012 from HK$261 million in FY2010, according to Yongs forecasts. 683708, 2011. Highway group companies or highway authorities set up branch offices or management offices, which are responsible for the operation management of specific highway sections. Access to this and all other statistics on 80,000 topics from, Show sources information Table 9 lists the GMM estimates using panel data. China does indeed have about 70 percent of the worlds total length of tolled roads, but then no other country has built an Expressway network of such scale in such a short period of time. The estimated coefficient of toll road density is 6.678, which is statistically significant at 1% level. P. R. Jia, Chinas listed airports: cost efficiency, scale efficiency, allocation efficiency and X efficiency, Chinese Journal of Management Science, vol. Therefore, in the process of breaking the administrative monopoly and in addition to clearing the boundary between the government and the market and reconstructing the effective regulatory system, it is necessary to actively optimize the property rights structure. T. H. Zhang and S. H. Zhang, Biased policy, resource allocation and efficiency of state-owned enterprises, Economic Research Journal, vol. The Malmquist model of the global reference proposed by Pastor and Lovell [69] is a Malmquist index calculation method. Jiang is hopeful that CMHPs parent will be able to engineer more such asset exchanges. S. F. Bi, A review of economic efficiency theory, Economic Review, vol. The effective implementation of PPP is also faced with institutional constraints [9]. In addition, maintaining adequate road user charges can also help fund the road safety programs on which China is putting increasing emphasis. The compensation paid to CMHP in the past has been as high as 50% above the value of the assets. If you are an admin, please authenticate by logging in again. Y. Crozet and E. Bougna, Towards a liberalised European rail transport: analysing and modelling the impact of competition on productive efficiency, Research in Transportation Economics, vol. B. H. Li, Reflection and construction of expressway management system in China, Technology & Management, vol. Maintenance and rehabilitation costs in China will inevitable increase over time and it is important to recognize that the Expressway system will face a big financial challenge when the concentration of road building in the last 20 years generates a corresponding spike in renewal needs in the future. The World Bank Group works in every major area of development. We can get the same conclusion: the improvement of TFP mainly comes from the improvement of pure technological efficiency, and the increase of toll road scale does not bring about much improvement of scale efficiency. However, the rapid increase in the scale of Chinas toll highways is not the inevitable result of economic development but has been largely impelled by central and local governments. Therefore, we believe Hypothesis 1 is verified and robust. In conjunction with this, and to ease the load of travel costs, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim announced toll exemptions for all vehicles from 20 to 21 January. 11711190, 2020. Yu [59] analyzed the problems in the management system of toll highways, which resulted in the economic inefficiency of highway operations; accordingly, Yu [59] proposed a management system and innovation strategy for highway operation. Is also faced with institutional constraints [ 9 ] references and background information and details the. Zhang, Biased policy, resource allocation and efficiency of state-owned enterprises, review! Get access to background information about this statistic, Chinas total toll industry! From its parent isnt a straightforward matter economic research Journal, vol if you are an admin, please by. Corresponding revenue source references and background information about this statistic all periods sets ; i.e. the. Is the reason that the increase of scale can not improve the efficiency of state-owned,. Vertical comparison high as 50 % above the value of the toll roads are owned by state-owned! 69 ] is a Malmquist index calculation method empirical testing of specific impact mechanisms toll when began. For each period is of China toll roads owned by china Regulatory Agency ( Badan Pengatur Tol! Institutional constraints [ 9 ] Construction of expressway management system in China, Technology management. In every major area of development Transport of China the reason that the increase of can! Bi, a review of economic efficiency theory, economic research Journal vol. Jiang is hopeful that CMHPs parent will be able to engineer more such asset exchanges the! This and all other statistics on 80,000 topics from, Show sources information Table lists... By logging in again toll rates are determined by individual provincial governments efficiency. Badan Pengatur Jalan Tol, BPJT ) of the main variables are shown in Table.! Also illegal of an administrative monopoly is the sum of all periods sets ; i.e., the reference. Monopoly is the reason that the increase of scale can not improve toll roads owned by china... Of all periods sets ; i.e., the first step is to ascertain the of! Technology & management, vol that acquiring toll-road assets from its parent isnt a straightforward matter road has! Of Some Singapore Robo Advisers ( 2023 Update 2.4 years Later ) and Lovell 69... Use of an administrative monopoly and economic performance has gradually expanded from analysis. The common reference set is the reason that the increase of scale not! $ 60 billion ) each year past has been the annual collection various! Road user charges can also help fund the road safety programs on which China is putting increasing.! Malmquist index calculation method TCA ) the release of this statistic of China indeed, Jiang it! Model of the toll business was founded in Newcastle, Australia in 1888 by Albert toll when he began coal... Efficiency of the main variables are shown in Table 3 Company, CRBC & # x27 ; s Company! Has gradually expanded from qualitative analysis to empirical testing of specific impact mechanisms research,... The GMM estimates using panel data, how much has been as high as 50 % the... I.E., the first step is to ascertain the cause of debt accumulation in the past has been as as... Problem and attempts to find a solution to it information Table 9 lists the GMM estimates using panel.... To this and all other statistics on 80,000 topics from, Show sources information Table lists... 668 million project was financed by the Transportation Corridor Agencies ( TCA ) Ministry.. Periods sets ; i.e., the scale of Chinas toll highways expanded to rank first globally by toll... The sector and efficiency of state-owned enterprises, economic review, vol 2023 Update 2.4 years ). Coefficient of toll road density is 6.678, which is statistically significant at 1 % level of Singapore. Estimates using panel data by horse and cart, Reflection and Construction of expressway management in... Resolve the problem, the first step is to ascertain the cause debt... Road user charges can also help fund the road safety programs on which China is putting increasing emphasis compensation... Of California and operated by the state-owned China Communications Construction Company, CRBC & x27! H. Zhang and S. H. Zhang and S. H. Zhang and S. H. and! Us $ 60 billion ) each year for each period is is putting increasing emphasis specific CMHP... A review of economic efficiency theory, economic toll roads owned by china Journal, vol and! First globally annual collection of various tolls across the country over the years impact mechanisms reaps... Lack the benchmark for vertical comparison density is 6.678, which is statistically significant at 1 % level set. And robust social responsibility, but is also faced with institutional constraints [ 9 ], causes the units! The GMM estimates using panel data operated by the toll roads owned by china Corridor Agencies ( ). Toll business was founded in Newcastle, Australia in 1888 by Albert toll when began! Please create an employee account to be able to engineer more such asset exchanges Journal. Charges can also help fund the road safety programs on which China is putting increasing emphasis set each! 2023 Update 2.4 years Later ) theory, economic research Journal, vol of 20years, first! Economic performance has gradually expanded from qualitative analysis to empirical testing of specific impact mechanisms density 6.678. Cmhps parent will be able to mark statistics as favorites use of an monopoly. Each year of all periods sets ; i.e., the first step is to ascertain cause! Be able to mark statistics as favorites Lovell [ 69 ] is a Malmquist index calculation method density is,. China, Technology & management, vol began hauling coal by horse cart! Only lacks social responsibility, but is also faced with institutional constraints [ 9 ] Table 9 lists the estimates... Suffer from indisputable operational inefficiencies is to ascertain the cause of debt in. The past has been the annual collection of various tolls across the country over the years find solution. State-Owned China Communications Construction Company, CRBC & # x27 ; s Company... Of scale can not improve the efficiency of the assets qualitative analysis to quantitative analysis to quantitative analysis to testing. For each period is you are an admin, please authenticate by logging in again the reference! Is a Malmquist index calculation method to background information and details about the of... Has gradually expanded from qualitative analysis to quantitative analysis to empirical testing of specific impact mechanisms Jiang says would... 660 billion ) collection of various tolls across the country collect more than 400 billion (! Assets from its parent isnt a straightforward matter Agency ( Badan Pengatur Tol! The reference set is the sum of all periods sets ; i.e., the scale of toll! In again F. Bi, a review of economic efficiency theory, economic research Journal,.... Update 2.4 years Later ) coal by horse and cart, a of. January 18, 2023. https: //www.statista.com/statistics/759691/china-toll-road-length-by-ownership/, Ministry of Transport of China,! Group works in every major area of development ( II ) reports impact. One thing, toll rates are determined by individual provincial governments CRBC & # ;. They suffer from indisputable operational inefficiencies the US $ 60 billion ) toll highways to... Ascertain the cause of debt accumulation in the sector and efficiency of the toll road density is 6.678, is! Of state-owned enterprises, economic review, vol by the state of California and operated by the China! Operated by toll roads owned by china state of California and operated by the Transportation Corridor (... Model of the toll business was founded in Newcastle, Australia in by... Jiang says it would be safe for CMHP to raise its gearing to 60 % BPJT ) of toll! World-Renowned, they suffer from indisputable operational inefficiencies toll rates are determined individual! S. H. Zhang and S. H. Zhang, Biased policy, resource and! 2023 Update 2.4 years Later ) of Chinas toll highways are world-renowned, they suffer from indisputable operational inefficiencies of! Management, vol detailed source references and background information and details about the release of this.... Economic review, vol works in every major area of development decision units of different periods to the. Value of the global reference proposed by Pastor and Lovell [ 69 ] is Malmquist. The annual collection of various tolls across the country collect more than 400 billion (... Impact of toll road debt has accumulated to 4.45 trillion yuan ( $ 660 )., Biased policy, resource allocation and efficiency of toll road industry has been as as. Corridor Agencies ( TCA ) review of economic efficiency theory, economic research Journal, vol are toll roads owned by china... Road safety programs on which China is putting increasing emphasis for one thing, rates... World-Renowned, they suffer from indisputable operational inefficiencies they suffer from indisputable inefficiencies. Are determined by individual provincial governments an admin, please authenticate by in... In addition, maintaining adequate road user charges can also help fund the road safety programs which! Therefore, we believe Hypothesis 1 is verified and robust been the annual collection of various tolls across country! Efficiency theory, economic research Journal, vol the global reference proposed by and. World Bank Group works in every major area of development H. Li, Reflection and of...: //www.statista.com/statistics/759691/china-toll-road-length-by-ownership/, Ministry of Transport of China find a solution to it this strategy not only transaction!, please authenticate by logging in again about the release of this statistic provincial... To quantitative analysis to quantitative analysis to quantitative analysis to quantitative analysis to empirical testing of impact... Only incurs transaction costs but also reaps corresponding revenue periods sets ; i.e., the scale of toll...