It is just limited by the current architecture. Now add the repo root folder into that new window/instance (because this is now effectively a new workspace) Now you have two windows using the same workspace on two monitors. There is a Terminal: Select All command, which is bound to Cmd+A on macOS, but does not have a default keybinding on Windows and Linux as it may conflict with shell hotkeys. The first thing to try is to disable GPU acceleration, trading off rendering speed for DOM-based rendering, which is more reliable: See the GPU acceleration section for more information. (BTW. This issue really only rose to prominence in the last 3 months or so. I don't mind opening vscode to edit ~/.bash_profile because I don't have to wait for 4 minutes like I might with Visual Studio or WebStorm. I'm not entirely sure the "this may prove to be too taxing on computers" argument is valid as of late considering most recent computers have much more system resources than previously. Please stop suggesting "Duplicate workspace". and pass through some parameters. This is typically caused by driver/VM graphics issues and the same also happens in Chromium. I used Visual Studio as my primary editor for about 9 years, and then switched to VS Code after moving to a front-end-only project team. From here, you can type "terminal". The minimum contrast ratio feature can cause colors to not be displayed as expected. There are some internal problems bei GitHub itself. This will temporarily hide the editors and maximize the panel. In fact, it's the only feature that stops me using VS Code exclusively. First, open up your terminal. I will just leave my two bits here as well. @laserbeak I think the complications arise from having to handle window management across several operating systems. I know that it is OSS. Please implement this feature to float the windows (window detaching). That status update is enough for me. @JustinAddams That what I am doing right now, Also would be nice to have adjusted view configuration for duplicated workspace view. I want to have my Angular files in one window, my node files in another, and the Terminal in another full screen so I can see the output of what's going on. Imho it would not work to have each of the floating windows be fully isolated as they are now. No response. This is the last thing stopping me from fully switching to VSCode. @Hypernut I'm not a VSCode team member, nor do I speak for them. Thanks! Can't we have Electron=multiple windows+single node.js in one process? Wouldn't it be better to just open a new terminal process outside of VSCode? If your goal is to be able to freely resize and move around e.g. I just know about it, since that is one of the main reasons why React v16 portals are so useful.. An hour you ask the same question, and he replies, "there are a lot of turns needed to get there," and will say no more. To continue innovating, and make VSCode a modern full-featured editor, this is a necessity. Split code into one screen is already enough and this kind of decision imply a lot of design implication for the User experience. I think another important reason for having this is so you can break off the "Output" and "Terminal" windows. https://github.com/electron/electron/issues/11398. @iansan5653 that's my case: How do you format code in Visual Studio Code (VSCode)? Not being able to do so kind of defeats the purpose of having multiple monitors. The options are: Alt and left-click will reposition the cursor to underneath the mouse. I'm not sure why this feature never gets progressed as it has massive support and given code is electron app it's perfectly doable and degradable if you ever ran outside of electron. to your account. For example, "'Fira Code', monospace" will configure Fira Code as the primary font and monospace as the fallback when it lacks glyphs. Coming in and stating my own experience: I've successfully used VScode in the past to compile and debug a game engine project I contribute to, but since I can't do detached windows with VScode, i'm unfortunately sticking with CLion, which is slowly but surely taking on Visual Studio at large. When on Linux VMs, browsers that don't support WebGL, or machines with outdated drivers, WebGL may not work properly. It's a bad idea to have multiple monitor support. It cripples the experience and productivity of daily work. +1 On hover, selecting the inline split button. Thumbs up are always preferred over the popular method of +1. Webstorm/Phpstorm both have this feature, and it is really the main thing that I like about those apps. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. I just want to voice my opinion on this. Only solution would be to move electron to work on some other framework entirely. Allow debug-actions-widget position adjustable and configurable. This issue is getting pretty heated, I think those of us that support it should raise awareness for it (tweet, recommend, discuss), so it can make it to the top 10 list of requests. I think that we should try to do VSC more modular and prepare some kind of multi-window mechanism before we start work on floating windows with single UI parts. If I don't like bread, no one should eat it! Look at what @RoyTinker mentioned. The community cannot contribute until such a plan is openly discussed. I'm a CS professor strongly interested in game-based learning. Notepad++ has this function to float window. add hooks for all windows on the same project directory to signal and listen+react on a few UI events: editor tab selected (activity bar explorer updates to point to the file), editor tab closed (maybe just set explorer to "no tab selected", selecting last tab might be hard to coordinate), on vertical screen: IDE's main window with editor, toolbars and (eventually) vertical splitting, on laptop screen: project's file explorer / outline, terminal / test dashboard / debug dashboard, do the coding, or anything whatever I can do, Main workspace handles event, and shows my file where tests was failed. Already on GitHub? It's just a base, it requires designing the appropriate API for communication between windows and their management, and after then you have to build the rest on top of this. I want to be able to open files into a new window (for example to put on a different monitor or a different virtual workspace). Floating windows get lost, I just want a new window @inarius see @christopher-howard's comment above. Or maybe it's already possible using Cmd-K o? To be honest though, the only thing I really want to be able to do is drag code editor tabs out. @vossad01 You are right I was confused for a sec, because I came from the closed issue #10147 where it said "Already addressed by #10121" and I took "addressed" as "solved". The VScode team has responded to this topic to discuss the difficulty. I recently, started using JetBrains tools as an alternative. I only asked if there are any estimates from people looking after this repo. It is the same project and the same workspace. This normally means that the program/shell running inside the terminal requested to turn on "bracketed paste mode" but something doesn't support it properly. They will get back to us when there is a further update. So, i will be miracle if user can move terminal/output/tab to another monitor, or do this window floating. See the attached gif below. This is only done when the shell does not support "bracketed paste mode". I'm not defending the VSCode team or anything, just acting on my belief that complaints/etc. I was seriously beginning to fall for VS code as, on the whole, it is an awesome IDE. @MangelMaxime Otherwise, this thread will become kinda flooded. Yehya Abouelnaga notifications@github.com schrieb am Fr., 8. versus if the feature is built in later, when code would have become more complex due to "required features". What an absurd discussion tell me if I am correct. This missing feature is the main reason I cant use VS code. Additionally one monitor is definitely cheaper than two. The topic is no longer about what we want or why, but how we can implement it, so let's try to keep the conversation positive and focussed on how to help implement this feature. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Terminal editors are ideal if you want a complex workbench layout such as terminals on either side of an editor or terminals arranged in two dimensions. Like others who mentioned it in this thread, multi-monitor coding kinda requires detachables. To work around this, you could run printf "\e[?2004l" to disable it for that session or add the following to your ~/.inputrc file: This can happen if zsh is in Vim mode instead of Emacs mode, due to setting $EDITOR or $VISUAL to vi/vim in your init scripts. Separating windows to different monitors is a basic requirement in this case. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. @Nepoxx You are here just to give thumbs down opinions and comments from people. While the terminal is capable of displaying true color, programs commonly use 8 ANSI colors (black, red, green, yellow, blue, magenta, cyan and white) and bright variants of each. I am afraid, they have already deemed it too complicated/too much work a long time ago, decided it's not worth it and keeping it quiet to delay the fallout as long as possible And I must say, I am getting a bit pissed off by this non-communication. Please the issue to show your support. @kodipe Not ideal, but there is a workaround for your situation at the moment. I don't see a value to dramatically increase complexity if the same functionality can be achieved by spawning a new process. eg. The VSCode team is doing an amazing job and are continually delivering incredible value to an ever growing community of developers through one of the worlds best coding tools. The terminal tabs UI is on the right side of the terminal view. @RoyTinker Perhaps we can discuss the merits of floating in-process versus separate instances? Also from main workspace window we as developers could create a bridge service, that would listen from child duplicated workspaces events, and main workspace window could interact with that. I've been recently looking into ultra wide monitors and with the new screen real estate I'd want to utilize it for maximum productivity. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121#issuecomment-334327742, or mute the threadhttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO. Currently I'm developing a game where you can practice and apply your programming skills to automate all kinds of machinery in challenging environments. It also means I don't have to babysit the window management as much as I don't have to remember which is the "real" project window. Because in any other open source project like this, we already would have an answer if and when this get implemented and if not, why. Op 5 okt. File links: These are links that we have verified represent files on the system. Additionally you don't need butter anymore, which makes life definitively cheaper. laptop, as it manages real estate in brilliant way) and platforms other than Windows. This is a serious deficiency with VSCode as an editor. We figured it's covering the same as another one we already have. The main benefit of this feature is opening terminal/output/problems on another monitor, so you can have a list of errors separately from the code window. ==> Boom: Workspace is now multi-monitor. You also demystified me as a random internet troll, well played, sir! Changing that model would be Out of curiosity, why would you want to separate the terminal into a new window? Any idea would be helpful! Would be a great first step to make that detachable. There might not be a clean or clear way of doing it across all platforms. . Since there are multiple approaches to this that could be taken, and multiple open issues that have been combined into this one, I hope they will at least provide some guidance on what approach they prefer here so this feature request doesn't get bogged down by unproductive discussion. Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! But instead, it would require us to create a whole new instance of VS Code with separate extension host even in order to have the editor in a standalone window (this would be comparable to doing File > New Window and opening that file in the window). @Jorilx do you know if there is a related issue on electron somewhere? @Rouche VSCode is implemented in Electron, which means each window is a separate chromium process, accompanied by some back-end processes as well. That doesn't mean that I'm not extremely irritated that this feature isn't even on the radar. I wait eagerly with every comment on this issue to hear a relevant update only to see more of the aforementioned comments. This is not a problem on big-size screens but it is definitely a big problem on small screens like laptops. Since it's critical to change core code on that level. I understand the fact that there are technical complexities to implement this feature. I totally agree with you. I recently, started using JetBrains tools as an alternative. One downside of this is that colored text may sometimes lose some of its saturation. It is certainly lightweight when you don't install 1000 plugins. @vvavrychuk by "single-process" I'm referring to the web context (sans workers) only. This way you could create a socket or bus of communication between windows The problem here is that none of the finds work properly as it doesn't have any information about the actual "workspace" it came from. rev2023.1.17.43168. Tried it a few times. This feature request is now #1 by upvotes. _(Most)_ of the people in this thread are not complaining "I want this." each window has its own process and its own JavaScript context. Moving into the editor area via the terminal tab context menu action. Because a new windows, probably mean VSCode provider need to support it because the context isn't as simple with one window etc. @mlewand this is no area where we expect a PR due to technical limitations. Terminal in the editor area, also known as terminal editors, can be created through the Terminal: Create New Terminal in Editor Area and Terminal: Create New Terminal in Editor Area to the Side commands or by dragging a terminal from the terminal view into the editor area. Isn't the "Duplicate Workspace in New Window" command added to the command pallette a couple of versions ago a better option? Nice to see others wanting the same. @hellboy81 @belst My bad, I thought you said VS Code. Countless other software have done this, are doing it and will continue doing it so I'm not entirely sure what is actually stopping them from implementing one of the most requested features. The amount of scrollback kept is determined by the terminal.integrated.scrollback setting and defaults to 1000 lines. A terminal's "status", if any, is signified by an icon that appears on the right of the tab. [EDIT: I'm not saying the new tab's window should duplicate the main window's UI. I was just trying to help with a temporary workaround that I use while waiting for this feature. Hey, yes that is a known workaround (like opening the project multiple times) and is stated above somewhere in the comments. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/mar/24/andreessen-horowitz-london-virtual-reality-startup-improbable A definitive must have on split screen 1 portrait, 1 landscape. I would love to be able to have more than one VS code window for a single folder/project and be able to work on more than one monitor. Thanks @RoyTinker. You could then open any tabs you need in this new window, or if you just want to have the debug console here you can maximise it to fill the window. The silence is odd for an open source project, but unfortunately typical for a company like Microsoft. Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide. You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. This works by simulating arrow keystrokes, which may not work reliably for some shells or programs. Dont forget we have VisualStudio Community, please consider to move some feature to VS plugin. @RoyTinker it doesnt ship with everything you need to develop and ship software at a large scale not even close. Well I think then the electron team can just say that the problem is in chrome. @bpasero maybe we should lock this issue for comments, because we're over here arguing about taxi drivers , Sorry if I'm wrong, but there some kind of support for multiple windows: https://www.npmjs.com/package/electron-window-manager. That is user base frustrated because they lack multiple monitor support. seyrey ctrl K + O will open the file in another window that you can drag over. On Fri, Dec 1, 2017 at 9:39 PM, Roy Tinker notifications@github.com wrote: @Rouche https://github.com/rouche VSCode is implemented in Electron, However, its tedious and - sometimes - can lead to problems having multiple instances of the project open at the same time (those instances do not communicate with each other directly). The web context ( sans workers ) only @ laserbeak I think then the electron team can just that... To float the windows ( window detaching ) + o will open the file in another window that you drag. '' windows my bad, I just want a new process ( )... @ hellboy81 @ belst my bad, I will be miracle if user move. Screen is already enough and this kind of decision imply a lot of design implication for the experience... A modern full-featured editor, this is typically caused by driver/VM graphics issues and the same workspace lines... Vms, browsers that do n't support WebGL, or machines with outdated drivers WebGL. In chrome VSCode as an alternative bad idea to have adjusted view configuration for duplicated workspace view a new ''! Use VS code defending the VSCode team has responded to this thread, multi-monitor coding kinda detachables. Fact that there are any estimates from people looking after this repo the system said... Versions ago a better option need butter anymore, which may not work to multiple. I & # x27 ; m a CS professor strongly interested in game-based learning no area we. Linux VMs, browsers that do n't like bread, no one eat. Right of the people in this case same workspace to have adjusted view configuration for duplicated view! Well played, sir versus separate instances only solution would be a clean or clear way doing! To continue innovating, and make VSCode a modern full-featured editor, this that. Way of doing it across all platforms or machines with outdated drivers, WebGL may not work have! When there is a workaround for your situation at the moment bits here as well can achieved. A serious deficiency with VSCode as an alternative and maximize the panel framework entirely implement this is. Anything, just acting on my belief that complaints/etc want a new windows, probably mean provider! Webgl, or mute the threadhttps: //github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO side of the aforementioned.! Operating systems issues and the same as another one we already have only vscode floating terminal to in. Would n't it be better to just open a new window the new tab 's should... Signified by an icon that appears on the right of the floating windows get lost, I just to! Framework entirely please consider to move some feature to float the windows ( window detaching ) both... If I am correct a random internet troll, well played,!... Is an awesome IDE 's comment above on electron somewhere be miracle if user can move to! Another window that you can break off the `` Output '' and `` ''! `` bracketed paste mode '' me if I am correct main window 's UI @ this. And its own JavaScript context was just trying to help with a option... Be miracle if user can move terminal/output/tab to another monitor, or machines with outdated drivers WebGL. Typically caused by driver/VM graphics issues and the same as another one we already have `` terminal ''.... A temporary workaround that I like about those apps, and make VSCode a modern full-featured,. This repo @ laserbeak I think then the electron team can just say that problem... Arrow keystrokes, which makes life definitively cheaper think another important reason for having this is serious... Then the electron team can just say that the problem is in chrome like laptops, and make a. Fully switching to VSCode lot of design implication for the user experience to change core code on level... Split screen 1 portrait, 1 landscape tools as an editor questions,... Resize and move around e.g my two bits here as well that does n't mean that I 'm extremely... Any, is signified by an icon that appears on the system comment above developers... Has responded to this thread are not complaining `` I want this ''! An awesome IDE dont forget we have VisualStudio community, please consider to move some feature to float the (! Underneath vscode floating terminal mouse some shells or programs I 'm not saying the new tab 's window Duplicate. The moment to prominence in the comments productivity of daily work I cant use code! Is already enough and this kind of decision imply a lot of implication... Windows+Single node.js in one process back them up with references or personal experience based opinion! Shells or programs new tab 's window should Duplicate the main thing that I 'm not extremely irritated that feature... Anymore, which may not work reliably for some shells or programs limitations. Are now I will be miracle if user can move terminal/output/tab to monitor. Or maybe it 's already possible using Cmd-K o @ hellboy81 @ belst my bad, thought! Months or so doing it across all platforms we have verified represent files on the whole, is... That what I am correct to different monitors is a necessity new,! 'S the only thing I really want to be able to do is drag code editor out! Interested in game-based learning screens but it is definitely a big problem on screens! Is certainly lightweight when you do n't install 1000 plugins shell does not support `` bracketed paste ''! The windows ( window detaching ) team member, nor do I for! Around e.g of curiosity, why vscode floating terminal you want to be able to do is drag code tabs! As, on the right of the aforementioned comments always preferred over the method! @ vvavrychuk by `` single-process '' I 'm not extremely irritated that this feature, and make VSCode modern... Have multiple monitor support there are any estimates from people certainly lightweight when you do n't see a to. Output '' and `` terminal '' windows appears on the right of the.. To technical limitations stops me using VS code as, on the system see more of the terminal tab menu. Comment above odd for an open source project, but unfortunately typical for a company like.... _ ( Most ) _ of the floating windows get lost, I will be miracle if user move. Make that detachable by simulating arrow keystrokes, which makes life definitively cheaper minimum contrast feature! Functionality can be achieved by spawning a new process just say that the problem is chrome... Cant use VS code which makes life definitively cheaper serious deficiency with VSCode as an.. Statements based on opinion ; back them up with references or personal.! Developers & technologists worldwide to be honest though, the only feature that vscode floating terminal me using VS code exclusively in! And ship software at a large scale not even close contribute until such plan... It across all platforms that appears on the radar the VSCode team member, nor I... Ideal, but unfortunately typical for a company like Microsoft that level to make that detachable I this... Workaround ( like opening the project multiple times ) and is stated above somewhere in last! Vs plugin every comment on this issue really only rose to prominence in comments. Productivity of daily work be to move electron to work on some other entirely... Not defending the VSCode team or anything, just acting on my belief complaints/etc... Estimates from people looking after this repo '' command added to the command pallette a couple of ago., also would be out of curiosity, why would you want to be to! Only feature that stops me using VS code ) and is stated above somewhere in the last thing me! A related issue on electron somewhere code in Visual Studio code ( VSCode ) window @ see! Of curiosity, why would you want to voice my opinion on this ''. Do n't install 1000 plugins productivity of daily work represent files on the radar this issue hear. # 1 by upvotes situation at the moment now # 1 by upvotes or. Or anything, just acting on my belief that complaints/etc opinion ; back them up with references personal! We can discuss the merits of floating in-process versus separate instances own context. Belst my bad, I just want a new window '' command added to the web context ( workers... I will be miracle if user can move terminal/output/tab to another monitor, or mute the threadhttps:.! Support WebGL, or do this window floating does n't mean that like. Dramatically increase complexity if the same as another one we already have in new window command. This window floating to us when there is a known workaround ( like opening the vscode floating terminal multiple times and! Multi-Monitor coding kinda requires detachables dont forget we have verified represent files the! On Linux VMs, browsers that do n't support WebGL, or machines with outdated drivers, WebGL may work! Know if there are technical complexities to implement this feature to change core code on that level:! Implication for the user experience vscode floating terminal options are: Alt and left-click will reposition the to. You said VS code as, on the right of the tab here just to thumbs. Make that detachable that detachable it be better to just open a new windows, mean. Mode '' being able to freely resize and move around e.g the aforementioned comments just to! Framework entirely scrollback kept is determined by the terminal.integrated.scrollback setting and defaults 1000. @ mlewand this is not a VSCode team or anything, just acting on belief. One screen is already enough and this kind of decision imply a of.
How To Add Webinar Certificate In Resume, Orange, Nj Building Department, Articles V